John and Kate make Alternate............ by Ralph

Okay....I'm watching,I'm watching, over and over again and something strikes me odd with Locke and Kate......

1st we will go with Kate(ladies first).....

I know that Kate uses alias but.....what if they are not aliases? What if every time we see SOME of Kate's flashbacks, they are actually alternate Kate's(Kinda like Jet Li in THE ONE,every alternate had a different name or variation of his name).I mean,sometimes Kate's back story is very blurred and makes no sense....

Example:

Kate claims that she used to go to the beach all the time with her Mom when she was a kid.

(Are there beaches in IOWA? or is this possibly a Kate who grew up in Florida and went on to marry Kevin the Orlando cop?).


Kate says she moved around a lot as a kid.

(But when Sam told Kate he wanted to take her with him,but Diane said "NO",also every time we see Kate as a child...She's hanging out with her doomed BF Tommy in Iowa-stealing NKOTB lunch boxes and making time capsules).

I think possibly that Kate is...

1) Lying.
2) Making up stories to spice up a abused and boring childhood.
3) possibly alternate reality Kate's.

(I might lean towards #2)

..Now...For John Locke.....

even though we have seen him with Nadia(inspecting her house)and with Randy(Hurley's old boss)....I think John Locke is from a different reality....what makes me believe this?

Geronimo Jackson.

It does not exist in Charlie Pace's and Sayid's world.Charlie and Hurley did not know the album and Charlie was serious about being an expert in all things musical and Sayid did not know them either....But Locke did( when he was flipping through the albums).

I think Geronimo Jackson exist in Locke's world and the island's reality.

We always see GJ albums in Locke's flashbacks....

1)In John's high school locker.
2)on Eddie's shirt(the undercover cop)

and of course Charlotte's ref to them.."turn it up, I love Geronimo Jackson!"

(now we did see a GJ album on the DJ table at Hurley's B-day party,which if you blink-you will miss it...I think that was just an Easter egg)

And my bonus theory.....

Randy?

Yes, Randy Nations!

....nothing does not line up with him?

Fact:Even though he was a d-bag to Hurley....Hurley gave Randy a job....Twice!(Hurley obviously likes Randy)

1)Mr.Clucks. and 2)Hurley's box company.

Now....

Mr.Clucks got hit with the space rock(being destroyed)and Hurley came home to leave for Australia right away(he even had dust and debris on him)...note...Randy had short hair and clean shaven.

The Box Company...Randy picks on Locke about him leaving for Australia.....note....Randy has bushy hair and goatee(makes me think of Mr.Spock's alternate self in "Mirror,Mirror" on Star trek).

these two scenarios seem to go on at the same time! and I think Randy is the CLUE the writers have put in since the start of LOST.

I mean, when Hurley got busted when he came back in 2005, Randy was right there filming him, would you not shout out to your Friend "Hurley! It's me Randy! What's going on?"....No,Hurley saw that Randy was there and DID NOT acknowledge him...Why? Maybe he does not know Randy in that reality?

and one last thing....what if Helen(Locke's girl) is only dead in one reality and alive in another(kinda like Peter Bishop in J.J.'s other show FRINGE)? What if Helen's head stone is what Locke needed to be shown to put him over the top(Helen meant the world to him,he called Kate "Helen" when he got knocked for a loop when Locke,Michael,and Kate were hunting boar in season 1)?

It just even seems that the show FRINGE is almost a study guide for LOST fans due to the similar subjects that FRINGE deal with and the DI experiment with( Teleportation, possession, alt reality, etc.,etc.....)



...well, that's my theory rant for today....what do you think?