from 109 "Solitary" - DANIELLE: Our vessel was 3 days out of Tahiti when our instruments malfunctioned... The ship slammed into rocks, ran aground, the hull breached beyond repair. So, we made camp, dug out this temporary shelter ... Temporary ... Nearly 2 months we survived here, 2 months before --
SAYID: Your distress signal? The message I heard, you said, "It killed them all."
DANIELLE: We were coming back from the Black Rock. It was them. They were the carriers...
from 123 (“Exodus, Part 1") :
DANIELLE: The Black Rock is not far. This is where it all began -- where my team got infected -- where Montand lost his arm.
So ... in Season 1, Danielle believed that her compatriots had been infected near the Black Rock, with a Personality-changing Sickness which they’d contracted from the Others who were “the [disease] carriers” and she believed that “The Monster” was no more than a Security System guarding the Island. In S1, Montand lost his arm near the Black Rock.
In 505, Montand lost his arm under the Temple and Team Danielle did not dig out a Jungle Shelter where they survived for nearly 2 months; instead, Danielle (on her own after the deaths of Nadia and Montand) returned to the Beach after the disaster at The Temple (not the Black Rock)
In 505, Danielle shot Brennan and Lacombe who had “returned” from the Temple as “Changelings” and laid them out side by side but unburied on the beach. She subsequently killed “Robert” after “he” persuaded her to lower her rifle so that he could (try to) shoot her - which proved that she had been right about him too having been “changed” by The Monster.
In 505, Danielle firmly believed in The Monster as much more than a Security System. Judging by the state of Montand’s arm and the state of the two beach corpses, Danielle shot Robert about a month after the Temple Disaster - but before giving birth to Alex.
In the 505 Iteration, she took a few parting rifle shots (all “misses”, natch) at Jin before he was snatched away by the Whiteout. Since these two Iterations of the Rousseau Saga are different, we don’t have to worry about whether S1-S4 Danielle “remembered” Jin. Theory by Roland
SAYID: Your distress signal? The message I heard, you said, "It killed them all."
DANIELLE: We were coming back from the Black Rock. It was them. They were the carriers...
from 123 (“Exodus, Part 1") :
DANIELLE: The Black Rock is not far. This is where it all began -- where my team got infected -- where Montand lost his arm.
So ... in Season 1, Danielle believed that her compatriots had been infected near the Black Rock, with a Personality-changing Sickness which they’d contracted from the Others who were “the [disease] carriers” and she believed that “The Monster” was no more than a Security System guarding the Island. In S1, Montand lost his arm near the Black Rock.
In 505, Montand lost his arm under the Temple and Team Danielle did not dig out a Jungle Shelter where they survived for nearly 2 months; instead, Danielle (on her own after the deaths of Nadia and Montand) returned to the Beach after the disaster at The Temple (not the Black Rock)
In 505, Danielle shot Brennan and Lacombe who had “returned” from the Temple as “Changelings” and laid them out side by side but unburied on the beach. She subsequently killed “Robert” after “he” persuaded her to lower her rifle so that he could (try to) shoot her - which proved that she had been right about him too having been “changed” by The Monster.
In 505, Danielle firmly believed in The Monster as much more than a Security System. Judging by the state of Montand’s arm and the state of the two beach corpses, Danielle shot Robert about a month after the Temple Disaster - but before giving birth to Alex.
In the 505 Iteration, she took a few parting rifle shots (all “misses”, natch) at Jin before he was snatched away by the Whiteout. Since these two Iterations of the Rousseau Saga are different, we don’t have to worry about whether S1-S4 Danielle “remembered” Jin. Theory by Roland
