Ben claimed that the person who turns the Frozen Donkey Wheel will never be able to return to the island, now alot off people have used the word "Banished" alot while referring to this, and while i cannot remember whether it was actually used in the show, i believe thats exactly what has happened to Ben.
Ben has been banished, but he CAN return to the island, but in doing so he will provoke Jacob's wrath, which will have disastrous results for the Island.
I believe this for three reasons, the first is the fact i believe that it will be a massive injustice to the show if Ben does not return to the island. Secondly it would make a really good storyline for Season 6 if they had to deal with the fallout off Jacob's wrath. And thirdly it would allow them to develop Jacob alot more.
And fourthly (i know i said three lol)...but it would in my opinion, be a REALLY awesome story lol
(sorry if theres any spelling mistakes lol, but i suck at spelling)
Theory by Stuart185
Ben has been banished, but he CAN return to the island, but in doing so he will provoke Jacob's wrath, which will have disastrous results for the Island.
I believe this for three reasons, the first is the fact i believe that it will be a massive injustice to the show if Ben does not return to the island. Secondly it would make a really good storyline for Season 6 if they had to deal with the fallout off Jacob's wrath. And thirdly it would allow them to develop Jacob alot more.
And fourthly (i know i said three lol)...but it would in my opinion, be a REALLY awesome story lol
(sorry if theres any spelling mistakes lol, but i suck at spelling)
Theory by Stuart185
