Ok. I'm a first time poster. Matter of fact I've never joined any of the lost, threads,forums,communities,etc....., but I've been reading them for the past two-three seasons of LOST.I now feel compelled. So please be kind to me because I'm new.
After tonites episode I began to wonder what would happen to the Ben we know in 2007 when he was killed by Sayid in 1977. (of course if he actually dies b/c this is LOST)Regardless we may have witnessed it when Locke saw him and told Cesar(i think that's his name) that he(Ben) was the man that killed him. Ben looked pretty bad for just being hit on the head with an oar, but at this point he may not have been murdered in the past(sounds weird) yet we simply don't know. I think something else may happen when someone we have known in our lost reality thus far dies in the past.CLAIRE !!!!! we may be more enlightened when we see if Ben is really dead/alive and what happens to his 2007 body/spirit.
OK now this is get a little confusing before I get to the point but here it goes. Claire just all of the sudden saw Christian in the woods and decided to leave Aaron (WTF). Next time we see her she's acting all weird in Jacob's cabin. I know that people have debated about weather she is dead or not. but what if she died because Danielle's past was changed somehow. Either by Jin's interaction with her OR the Others never came to get her baby because they don't have makin baby problems in the 80's when she came to the Island or at all. If Dannielle was not in the right place at the right time Claire could have possibly died during child bith or BEN killed(no pun intended). The reason I think Danielle's past has changed is because the NUMBERS message was playing NOT her french message when the Arujia flight landed. I'm pretty sure everyone's aware of the numbers playing over the plane's radio. I don't know how this would work in a timeline sense and I would love some input back on it. When claire walked off with Christian she was possibly removed from time in a sense, but since she actually did exist in 2004 she is stuck somehow in time possibly like some have said JACOB & Christian possibly are.
Now the biggest argument I have againt claire being dead is that Aaron still exists after she dies/goes away. Yea that's right I am arguing with myself.
In all of this Thinking I have been doing with this I came up with the following Theory.I will try to keep this short.
Everyone that is on the island in 2007 will witness the island going through significant changes right in front of their eyes. Maybe the runway will vanish. Maybe Ben Vanishes. Maybe been gets stuck like claire. Maybe Dharma continued on after bens' death because he wasnt there to purge anymore.Maybe there are not any makin baby problems anymore. Maybe every little thing that our losties do in 1977 changes things, all kinds of things and all of our newbies will have to somehow deal with all this.
Let's face it Ben Really screwed things up.I believe Ben was somehow complacent with the island/JACOB and at the same time defied the Island/JACOB by persuing Juliet because that dude is FREAKY about Juliet. Ben somehow used his knowledge from the past for his own personal gain and The Island/Jacob are trying course correct. So the Island is now eliminating him somehow so ben can't screw the island's future up. I don't think Ben is good or bad like many have said before.I just think he is Selfish and was a mistake on the Island/Jacob's part. BEN SCREWED EVERYTHING UP. Ben has been so focused on keeping Widmore away for some reason.I think because Widmore would have been better suited to handle things on the island and if Widmore comes back then Ben could not get what he originally wanted in the first place for"serving the Island" Juliet.Now Sayid has gone back in time to bite past Ben in the ass. So ben may no longer be a factor. BTW That would be why the runway would dissapear because I think Ben is the one who wanted to build it.
Therefore Faraday could be right about whatever happens happens because the purge/incident or what ever caused all of theese problems on the island (EXAMPLEs: some kind of weird disease that no one talks about anymore, problems with pregnancies, fighting,TIME JUMPING, TIME SKIPPING,THE MISSUSE OF ELECTROMAGNETIC FORCES etc...) was never supposed to happen. And we are now going to witness the island course correcting itself.
Walt told John that he had dreams to the tune that John was on the island and everyone he was around wanted to kill him. Maybe this war that Widmore is talking about will be fought in the past and future. With both the past and the future(present) having good guys / bad guys. Some of the people that are now on the island in 2007 are there to see their side come through all of this or to somehow hinder or assist things. Some may be scared of John because it is obvious to them that he is special and knows whats going on. Also some people from the past may have found a way to travel forward and get the skinny on what future events lie ahead to prepare for things. My example of this is Horace Godspeed running into John Locke in the middle of the woods with his nose bleeding. I think this is Horace possibly spying on or guiding future John to bring certain people to the island past.This would be different than Ben abusing the Islands powers for himself but rather Horace using the powers because the Island/Jacob told him to so it would make right their mistake(s).
Okay I think I'm done because I don't even know if this makes sense.
HOPE YOU ENJOYED MY FIRST OFFICIAL LOST THEORY. ONCE AGAIN PLEASE BE NICE. That is why I picked this site because everyone seems nice.
I KNOW SOME OF THIS HAS BEEN DISCUSSED BUT I REALLY FEEL LIKE I'M ADDING TO EVERYONES OPINIONS/THEORIES THAT I HAVE AGREED WITH OVER THE YEARS.PLEASE TELL ME IF I'M NOT CONTIBUTING BUT I THINK I AM HELPING PUT MORE PIECES OF THE PUZZLE TOGETHER.Theory by Daniel
After tonites episode I began to wonder what would happen to the Ben we know in 2007 when he was killed by Sayid in 1977. (of course if he actually dies b/c this is LOST)Regardless we may have witnessed it when Locke saw him and told Cesar(i think that's his name) that he(Ben) was the man that killed him. Ben looked pretty bad for just being hit on the head with an oar, but at this point he may not have been murdered in the past(sounds weird) yet we simply don't know. I think something else may happen when someone we have known in our lost reality thus far dies in the past.CLAIRE !!!!! we may be more enlightened when we see if Ben is really dead/alive and what happens to his 2007 body/spirit.
OK now this is get a little confusing before I get to the point but here it goes. Claire just all of the sudden saw Christian in the woods and decided to leave Aaron (WTF). Next time we see her she's acting all weird in Jacob's cabin. I know that people have debated about weather she is dead or not. but what if she died because Danielle's past was changed somehow. Either by Jin's interaction with her OR the Others never came to get her baby because they don't have makin baby problems in the 80's when she came to the Island or at all. If Dannielle was not in the right place at the right time Claire could have possibly died during child bith or BEN killed(no pun intended). The reason I think Danielle's past has changed is because the NUMBERS message was playing NOT her french message when the Arujia flight landed. I'm pretty sure everyone's aware of the numbers playing over the plane's radio. I don't know how this would work in a timeline sense and I would love some input back on it. When claire walked off with Christian she was possibly removed from time in a sense, but since she actually did exist in 2004 she is stuck somehow in time possibly like some have said JACOB & Christian possibly are.
Now the biggest argument I have againt claire being dead is that Aaron still exists after she dies/goes away. Yea that's right I am arguing with myself.
In all of this Thinking I have been doing with this I came up with the following Theory.I will try to keep this short.
Everyone that is on the island in 2007 will witness the island going through significant changes right in front of their eyes. Maybe the runway will vanish. Maybe Ben Vanishes. Maybe been gets stuck like claire. Maybe Dharma continued on after bens' death because he wasnt there to purge anymore.Maybe there are not any makin baby problems anymore. Maybe every little thing that our losties do in 1977 changes things, all kinds of things and all of our newbies will have to somehow deal with all this.
Let's face it Ben Really screwed things up.I believe Ben was somehow complacent with the island/JACOB and at the same time defied the Island/JACOB by persuing Juliet because that dude is FREAKY about Juliet. Ben somehow used his knowledge from the past for his own personal gain and The Island/Jacob are trying course correct. So the Island is now eliminating him somehow so ben can't screw the island's future up. I don't think Ben is good or bad like many have said before.I just think he is Selfish and was a mistake on the Island/Jacob's part. BEN SCREWED EVERYTHING UP. Ben has been so focused on keeping Widmore away for some reason.I think because Widmore would have been better suited to handle things on the island and if Widmore comes back then Ben could not get what he originally wanted in the first place for"serving the Island" Juliet.Now Sayid has gone back in time to bite past Ben in the ass. So ben may no longer be a factor. BTW That would be why the runway would dissapear because I think Ben is the one who wanted to build it.
Therefore Faraday could be right about whatever happens happens because the purge/incident or what ever caused all of theese problems on the island (EXAMPLEs: some kind of weird disease that no one talks about anymore, problems with pregnancies, fighting,TIME JUMPING, TIME SKIPPING,THE MISSUSE OF ELECTROMAGNETIC FORCES etc...) was never supposed to happen. And we are now going to witness the island course correcting itself.
Walt told John that he had dreams to the tune that John was on the island and everyone he was around wanted to kill him. Maybe this war that Widmore is talking about will be fought in the past and future. With both the past and the future(present) having good guys / bad guys. Some of the people that are now on the island in 2007 are there to see their side come through all of this or to somehow hinder or assist things. Some may be scared of John because it is obvious to them that he is special and knows whats going on. Also some people from the past may have found a way to travel forward and get the skinny on what future events lie ahead to prepare for things. My example of this is Horace Godspeed running into John Locke in the middle of the woods with his nose bleeding. I think this is Horace possibly spying on or guiding future John to bring certain people to the island past.This would be different than Ben abusing the Islands powers for himself but rather Horace using the powers because the Island/Jacob told him to so it would make right their mistake(s).
Okay I think I'm done because I don't even know if this makes sense.
HOPE YOU ENJOYED MY FIRST OFFICIAL LOST THEORY. ONCE AGAIN PLEASE BE NICE. That is why I picked this site because everyone seems nice.
I KNOW SOME OF THIS HAS BEEN DISCUSSED BUT I REALLY FEEL LIKE I'M ADDING TO EVERYONES OPINIONS/THEORIES THAT I HAVE AGREED WITH OVER THE YEARS.PLEASE TELL ME IF I'M NOT CONTIBUTING BUT I THINK I AM HELPING PUT MORE PIECES OF THE PUZZLE TOGETHER.Theory by Daniel
