I was thinking the other day about charlie. When he died he was technically off the island. So if his body were to wash ashore would he awaken? Or if he died on the island in the water if he somehow got away from the island would he come back to life in the real world?
The reason i came to this conclusion is this. Locke died off the island. He was a sacrifice, and he was murdered. Charlie situation was similar. He also did what he did knowing full well he was going to die.
i was thinking about all this because who convinced Hurley so quickly into returning to the island when he was so dead set against it. I think maybe if charlie came back to life that would really convince him. and if he came back to life he couldn't go back to the island because he would die. So maybe he has Aaron right now because he was like a father to him. Most likely though he is dead and appeared to Kate and Hurley as a ghost, for hurley again. Maybe a ghost came to everyone and convinced them to come back when locke couldn't.
we already know jack saw his dead father.........
hurley saw charlie once......
kate saw claire in a dream.....
who knows maybe im wrong.Theory by rob42164
The reason i came to this conclusion is this. Locke died off the island. He was a sacrifice, and he was murdered. Charlie situation was similar. He also did what he did knowing full well he was going to die.
i was thinking about all this because who convinced Hurley so quickly into returning to the island when he was so dead set against it. I think maybe if charlie came back to life that would really convince him. and if he came back to life he couldn't go back to the island because he would die. So maybe he has Aaron right now because he was like a father to him. Most likely though he is dead and appeared to Kate and Hurley as a ghost, for hurley again. Maybe a ghost came to everyone and convinced them to come back when locke couldn't.
we already know jack saw his dead father.........
hurley saw charlie once......
kate saw claire in a dream.....
who knows maybe im wrong.Theory by rob42164