New Timline Theory-Two Timlines and how they both ALWAYS existed by Dogma9

Okay, so I had sorta an "aha" moment here.

I got to thinking, IF (big If) Lost decides to do a reset, what happens in the past?? What happens in the 1970's???

My guess is, even if 815 lands in LAX. WHH, will stay have a role.

My guess is, those LAX Losties will STILL have to time travel into the past (because they did on the island too)

So, I got to thinking, if time travel the EXACT same way off island, as it did ON island, then the the timeline might finally makes sense.

My one big question sense reading all the reset theories,

Is "if change is possible, how did the Losties show up in the past from a future that hasn’t happened yet? (Because, if change IS possible, the future they came from would not be written in stone right?)

And WHAT could have changed to make jughead go off?? Something must have changed, what was it?

Now this is all just a theory,

So it may not work out that way, just bare with me.

Timeline A is the show wev been watching when the Swan was built.

Timeline B is the alternate reality. Where 815 lands in LA.

So, let’s start in Timeline B, the timeline A Losties go back in time (Jack, Sawyer, Kate, exct) and eventually cause the detonation of jughead. This destroys the swan's energy, thus creating the timeline B, where 815 never crashed.

So the timeline A Losties, are flashed through time (maybe they go to the Orchid, im unsure), and that’s the last we see of them for a while.

Meanwhile, the new timeline B Losties are born off island.

They grow up in slightly different circumstance, and they get on flight 815.

815 don’t crash, and they go and live their lives off island. But things keep happening the same EXACT way. Boone dies, Charlie dies, and Jack gets visions of the island. Stuff like this,

Now, my theory is that the Losties will slowly start to remember their past life (see you in another life brotha). Once they do, and after seeing that "nothing will change" off island or not,

The Losties come to realize that they cannot outrun their destiny. They begin to wish they’d stayed on the island/not changed things.


Then, at the exact same time as in the original timeline, Jacob (Who will be working on the LA Losties, trying to convince them to go back)

Will send the timeline B Losties flashing through time again.

Only this time, they have FINALLY realized that their destiny is on the island.


So, the timeline B Losties decide to let the Incident occur and NOT detonate jughead. They live out the rest of their lives on the island, and die in the purge (Richard=I watched them all die)


So, by allowing the Incident to happen, the timeline B Losties, have effectivly created timeline A

Do you see where im going with this??

The timelines...are like synergy. One CANNOT exist without the other.

In time line A(The show wev been watching from day 1), its the Timeline B Losties that always ended up in the past, who finally understand the island is their destiny, and allowed the Incident to occur.

(This is why Jacob was allowed to guide them to the island. because he knows is the timeline B Losties that CHOSE to let their destiny play out this way)

In timeline B, it’s the timeline A Losties that always ended up in the past, who went through hell, and thus set off jughead.


This would not only give us an Alternate reality, that could hopefully show us some cool answers in a cool way,

BUT it would help explain where the Timeline A past Losties came from, despite the fact that future hadn’t happen yet (they where from Timeline B, where they lived off island)

And better yet,

It would remove timeline B (So in the end, we only have 1 timeline), and create the timeline wev been watching from day 1.


My guess is, after Timeline B Losties allow the Incident to happen,

We will finally see the Jughead Losties end up in 2007,

To finish the war. (Thus allowing us to watch the Losties wev been seeing from day 1)

The final piece of proof?? Adam and Even.(Jack and Kate)

Proof that the timeline B LAX Losties always end up in the past, and thus live out their lives on the island.

Thoughts??(Also feel free to ask for clarification, its complicated I know....: P)