Season 2 finale Live Together, Die Alone Desmond finds out that the day he didn't push the button was the same day Flight 815 crashed on the island.
"What day did you come here?"
"60, 65 days"
"No the date, what was the date?"
"It was september 22nd!"
"I think i crashed your plane."
Desmond said i THINK i crashed your plane. But did we ever get 100% proof that it was his fault. We all just assumed that Desmond was the reason for the crash. But what if...What if it wasn't his fault?
Jack believes that it is his destiny to prevent the incident from ever happening and therefore preventing their plane from crashing. Good for jack, but there is one problem with your theory jack if The magnet wasn't the reason your plane crashed. Well if it wasn't Desmond then what? It was Jacob. Sounds far fetched, but he is the one who selected each and everyone of them. He is the one that chose the 48 survivors to survive the crash. Jacob brought the plane to the island weather through the button or not...
So if jughead truly did detonate then jacks theory would work...partly.... by detonating jughead they did indeed change the future. But not the way they thought since the button never had anything to do with the plane crashing in the first place. It's the happy medium between WHH and Erasing the first 5 seasons. Jughead changed the future but it still didn't change the fact that the survivors ended up on the island since the swan station magnet wasn't the reason Flight 815 crashed.
A little proof to back my theory. Episode 9 Namaste of Season 5 Dharmaville in 07 has registration signs and is all still Dharmatized. Also in Episode 1 of Season 3 Tale of Two Cities, the others experience none of the effects witnessed in Live Together, Die Alone after locke breaks the computer and the button isn't pushed. Lastly, we all know Darlton won't erase the first 5 seasons, but we also know that not all the 77 survivors can be dead. So there has to be a happy medium.
Summary
-Desmond didn't crash Flight 815
-Jacob brought the survivors to the island
-Jughead did detonate
-The future did change, but not entirely
-Flight 815 still crashes but things are much different in present time (Dharmaville)
"What day did you come here?"
"60, 65 days"
"No the date, what was the date?"
"It was september 22nd!"
"I think i crashed your plane."
Desmond said i THINK i crashed your plane. But did we ever get 100% proof that it was his fault. We all just assumed that Desmond was the reason for the crash. But what if...What if it wasn't his fault?
Jack believes that it is his destiny to prevent the incident from ever happening and therefore preventing their plane from crashing. Good for jack, but there is one problem with your theory jack if The magnet wasn't the reason your plane crashed. Well if it wasn't Desmond then what? It was Jacob. Sounds far fetched, but he is the one who selected each and everyone of them. He is the one that chose the 48 survivors to survive the crash. Jacob brought the plane to the island weather through the button or not...
So if jughead truly did detonate then jacks theory would work...partly.... by detonating jughead they did indeed change the future. But not the way they thought since the button never had anything to do with the plane crashing in the first place. It's the happy medium between WHH and Erasing the first 5 seasons. Jughead changed the future but it still didn't change the fact that the survivors ended up on the island since the swan station magnet wasn't the reason Flight 815 crashed.
A little proof to back my theory. Episode 9 Namaste of Season 5 Dharmaville in 07 has registration signs and is all still Dharmatized. Also in Episode 1 of Season 3 Tale of Two Cities, the others experience none of the effects witnessed in Live Together, Die Alone after locke breaks the computer and the button isn't pushed. Lastly, we all know Darlton won't erase the first 5 seasons, but we also know that not all the 77 survivors can be dead. So there has to be a happy medium.
Summary
-Desmond didn't crash Flight 815
-Jacob brought the survivors to the island
-Jughead did detonate
-The future did change, but not entirely
-Flight 815 still crashes but things are much different in present time (Dharmaville)
