Charlie Hume & Charles Widmore are one in the same…..
First of all, from the moment I found out that Alex was not Bens “real” daughter, I knew that the possibility of a false or skewed relationships between other characters could be possible as well. As much as Ben told people that Alex was his daughter she in fact was not.
So,…… after watching The Variable, I came up with my theory that Charles Widmore and Charlie Hume were one in the same…. You might be asking yourself “how can that be? That would make Penny Charles Widmore’s daughter and…. Mother?” Well, I thought the same as you, but soon realized there is no firm evidence that Penny is even Charles Widmores “actual daughter”, aside from Widmore saying that she is, which could be a lie….. as we saw with Ben and Alex. Would it be so absurd to theorize that Charles Widmore took Penny in as his daughter early in her life, just as Ben did for Alex? Well, that is what I believe happened.
Facts
1. Widmore leaves the island several times and impregnates “a women” ultimately leading to his banishment from the island.
2. We all assumed that the child would be Penny but then found out that Faraday is actually the child of Hawking and Widmore.
3. Eloise does not claim Penny as her daughter and Widmore never speaks of Penny’s mother.
Co-existing...
Now, there is the issue of Adult Charles Widmore existing at the same time as baby Charlie Hume (baby Widmore). Well, where do we see this happening already? Miles! Miles is in “Dharma time” existing at the same time as his infant self and he’s just fine.
So… maybe Charles Widmore grows up on the island, takes Penny in as a child and calls her his “daughter” because he finds out that she will be/is his mother! Also, since Eloise acquired Faraday’s journal, Widmore would probably find out about Desmond Hume being his son’s (Faraday) constant, so when a man named Desmond comes into Widmore’s life, it becomes obvious that Widmore would not want them to marry. Would you want your mom to marry a guy that would end up on an island for 3 years to push a button? No. haha
Things I need answered soon to help my theory
1. Who is Penny’s mother?
2. Is Widmore Penny’s actual father or did he just adopt her?
3. Does baby Charlie Hume get taken away from his parents Penny Widmore and Desmond Hume?
Predictions:
I think that baby Charlie Hume will be taken to the island (by hostiles maybe? They’ve taken children before right?) and travels back in time (like the O6 did, just further in the past) and grows up on the island with Richard and the other hostiles. This is where I believe our story for the hostiles will begin..
First of all, from the moment I found out that Alex was not Bens “real” daughter, I knew that the possibility of a false or skewed relationships between other characters could be possible as well. As much as Ben told people that Alex was his daughter she in fact was not.
So,…… after watching The Variable, I came up with my theory that Charles Widmore and Charlie Hume were one in the same…. You might be asking yourself “how can that be? That would make Penny Charles Widmore’s daughter and…. Mother?” Well, I thought the same as you, but soon realized there is no firm evidence that Penny is even Charles Widmores “actual daughter”, aside from Widmore saying that she is, which could be a lie….. as we saw with Ben and Alex. Would it be so absurd to theorize that Charles Widmore took Penny in as his daughter early in her life, just as Ben did for Alex? Well, that is what I believe happened.
Facts
1. Widmore leaves the island several times and impregnates “a women” ultimately leading to his banishment from the island.
2. We all assumed that the child would be Penny but then found out that Faraday is actually the child of Hawking and Widmore.
3. Eloise does not claim Penny as her daughter and Widmore never speaks of Penny’s mother.
Co-existing...
Now, there is the issue of Adult Charles Widmore existing at the same time as baby Charlie Hume (baby Widmore). Well, where do we see this happening already? Miles! Miles is in “Dharma time” existing at the same time as his infant self and he’s just fine.
So… maybe Charles Widmore grows up on the island, takes Penny in as a child and calls her his “daughter” because he finds out that she will be/is his mother! Also, since Eloise acquired Faraday’s journal, Widmore would probably find out about Desmond Hume being his son’s (Faraday) constant, so when a man named Desmond comes into Widmore’s life, it becomes obvious that Widmore would not want them to marry. Would you want your mom to marry a guy that would end up on an island for 3 years to push a button? No. haha
Things I need answered soon to help my theory
1. Who is Penny’s mother?
2. Is Widmore Penny’s actual father or did he just adopt her?
3. Does baby Charlie Hume get taken away from his parents Penny Widmore and Desmond Hume?
Predictions:
I think that baby Charlie Hume will be taken to the island (by hostiles maybe? They’ve taken children before right?) and travels back in time (like the O6 did, just further in the past) and grows up on the island with Richard and the other hostiles. This is where I believe our story for the hostiles will begin..
